As a youth, Eddie came into the town with his gang to rob the bank, but was caught and convicted. Marshal Ben helped him to become a honorable citizen. Now, many years later, the gang returns to again rob the bank. On their flight they shoot the Marshal. Eddie is the only one to identify the murderer - but is in doubt if he shall be loyal to his new or his old friends.
Unfortunately the movie Good Day for a Hanging is not yet available on HBO Max.
| Directing | Nathan Juran | Director |
| Writing | Daniel B. Ullman | Screenplay |
| Writing | Maurice Zimm | Screenplay |
| Writing | John Reese | Story |
| Camera | Henry Freulich | Director of Photography |
| Art | Robert Peterson | Art Direction |
| Art | Frank Tuttle | Set Decoration |
| Editing | Jerome Thoms | Editor |
| Directing | Sam Nelson | Assistant Director |
| Production | Charles H. Schneer | Producer |
